XXX
XXX
XXX
XXXX
XXX
XXX
XXX
Joseph Hazelton's eyewtiness account of
Lincoln's assassination.  He was an errand
boy at Ford's Theater the night Lincoln was
shot.
www.historyforsale.com/productimages/jpeg/84446.jpg
assassinated, Parker was in charge of
guarding the president. On May 1, 1865,
Parker was charged with neglect of duty in
connection with the assassination. He was
tried but the case was dismissed in June
1865. Parker died in Washington D.C. years
later of pneumonia, asthma and exhaustion.
He was buried beside his children in
Glenwood Cemetery there. Parker's wife died
in 1904, and is also buried beside him. The
specific plot is not marked.

Note that the article from Smithsonian
Magazine states there is no photos of John
Parker, but the one above was posted on
FindaGrave.
www.findagrave.com/cgi-bin/fg.cgi...
XXXXX
How Tom and Fiona Solved the Puzzle
XXX
XXX
INTERVIEWS
PAST
APPEARANCES
MAGAZINE
ARTICLES
BOOKSTORE
PHOTOQUIZ
SURVEYS
LINKS
WEEKLY QUIZ
FORENSIC ID
PROJECTS
ABOUT US
Quiz #433 Results
Bookmark and Share
Answer to Quiz #433 - March 16, 2014
**********
1. What was this man's name?
2. What was his claim to fame?
3. Who was he with when his "claim to fame" occurred?
UPCOMING EVENTS
**********
CONTACT US
QUIZMASTER
ROGUES GALLERY
Answers:
1.  Sidney J. Seymour
2.  Las living person to be present at Lincoln's assassination.
3.  His godmother Mrs. Goldsboro and his nurse Sarah Cook
**********
If you have a picture you'd like us to feature a picture in a future quiz, please
email it to us at
CFitzp@aol.com. If we use it, you will receive a free analysis of
your picture. You will also receive a free
Forensic Genealogy CD or a 10%
discount towards the purchase of the
Forensic Genealogy book.
Counter
If you enjoy our quizzes, don't forget to order our books!
Click
here.
!-- Start Quantcast tag -->
Comments from Our Readers
Do you believe the story? I wonder if Samuel Seymour's godmother ever wrote
about the experience. What would he have told his parents after Lincoln died?
Grace Hertz and Mary Turner
Didn't pick up this contest until 3/22. Googled images for "ive got a secret old
man" and recognized a similar person near the top of the results. That page
led to (eventually) the newspaper article that stimulated the TV invitation.
Collier Smith
This is one of the quizzes that makes me feel like I  almost had an opportunity to
just reach out and touch an historical event but somehow I missed it. Like it was
just rrriiiiighht there, and now it's gone.

I've found nothing to document this other than the show and the original article in
1954. I'm still thinking. Sarah Cook was 14 at the time from what I've read.  He
was 5. The investigators probably would've overlooked them in the investigation.
You would think Mrs. Goldsboro would have left something somewhere sometime
relaying what she saw.  

Very interesting about Rathbone. And very sad. Traumatic memories are haunting.
I'm still reading up on him.
Kim Richardson
This one was easy... 5 minute solve... In February 1956, two months before his
death, 96-year-old Samuel J. Seymour appeared on the CBS television show "I've
Got A Secret"; His secret: he witnessed Abraham Lincoln's assassination when he
was five years old.
Stephen P. Hall
Googled "I've Got a Secret" and found the IMDb website which had Samuel
Seymour's secret as one of the trivia for the show. So then went looking for
Samuel Seymour and found several images that suggested I was on the right track.

Really want to find out Mrs George S Goldsboro's name and whether she was
his godmother or just his father's clients wife.
Fiona Brooker
I found it disturbing to learn that Seymour died 3 days before the 91st anniversary
of the assassination and that his health had begun to fail after he fell in a NY hotel
the night before he was to appear on the  TV show "I've Got A Secret". I say the
show is responsible for this death twice over--they also gave him a tin of tobacco.
Tynan Peterson
N.B.  When you are that age, who cares if you smoke?  - Q. Gen.
I found the episode where he appeared on I've Got A Secret by simply Googling
"Old man on I've Got a Secret" One hit was to a YouTube video which showed the
episode pictured in the quiz photo. It aired on Feb. 9, 1956 when Mr. Seymour was
96 years old. There was also a link there to a Milwaukee Sentinel newspaper
interview with Mr.   Seymour on Feb. 7, 1964..
Ellen Welker
Amazing! I am struck by Mr Seymour's recollection of being "shot 50 times that
night" (in his dreams).
Diane Abbott
I was pretty impressed by how quickly the panel came up with his secret.  My
family watched that TV show all of the time.

I read about Major Rathbone.  On Wikipedia it says the cemetery location where he
and his wife were buried lacked activity so the bodies were disposed of.  That’s the
final insult to a tragic life.
Carol Farrant
I had seen this before on YouTube.
Larry Adams
I recognized Garry Moore and of course the set tells us this is from an episode of
I've Got a Secret. I went to imdb.com and looked at the cast members only
appearing once. I started selecting names I didn't recognize and checked out
Samuel J. Seymour. From Googling his name I found this image and saw that his
claim to fame was that he was he last surviving person who had been present in
Ford's Theater the night of the shooting of U.S. President Abraham Lincoln
on April 14, 1865.
Patty K
The Wikipedia page for I've Got a Secret narrowed things down to the period
from 1953 to 1964; looking through the list of YouTube clips at the bottom of
that page, the one entitled "Witness of Lincoln's Assassination" kind of stands out...
Roger Lipsett
After finding that particular TV game show on You Tube, I spent a pleasant hour or
so watching and reminiscing over several other game shows from the late 50s and
early 60s.
Venita Wilson
there is a whole book of eyewitness accounts written about 10 years ago(or maybe
less), which contains the statements of 100 people who were in Ford's Theater that
night and saw the assassination. Some of the statements were taken  the night of
the shooting, some were recollections recorded years later, but they pretty much
match up, depending on where the witness was located when the shooting
occurred. I remember one of them was from one of the actors who was on the
stage when Booth jumped from the box to the stage.

The ...book covers a large number of the eyewitness accounts. The book is
entitled, We Saw Lincoln Shot: One Hundred Eyewitness Accounts. Timothy Good
was the author, and it is still available from Amazon. I don't know if Mr. Seymour's
account is in the book or not. I may order the Kindle version and read it.
Bill Utterback
Well, I just find this game to be fascinating.  Research is fun for me, it is part of
me, and I just do it naturally.  Also, I read a lot and have many varied interests, so I
have some intersections of knowledge in my lexicon that are pretty novel, plus
years of research experience allows me to know shortcuts and resources.  You
know, I thought the same exact thing about the supposed witness to the Lincoln
event.  At the time of the event and just after, or even years and years after, you
would think that the whole family of everyone involved would have known this
story and passed it on religiously.  I find it questionable for the very reason that
they didn't.  Why would they have kept that a secret?  At any rate, in my research
into my own family and researching other people's families, I have found that
sometimes people repeat a story so much that they themselves either think its true,
or it has escalated to the point that the lie is unretractable.  I am not saying that Mr.
Seymour was a liar, but I do find the whole scenario unlikely and most definitely
questionable.
Martha Rice
I have a Rathbones in my family tree, but no Henry. I'll have to dig into this.
Tom Collins
I agree re the other accounts. Is it just a case of he was around the longest and so
had got to the "modern" age where stories like this became more popular. Did
others leave diaries of the events that are in private collections or destroyed. I
would have thought it would have been the sort of story to be passed down
generations.

I did read about Rathbone and the rest of the plot to assassinate the others in power
at the time too. I also read that the guard outside the door had gone to the pub next
door for a drink. See more here:

www.smithsonianmag.com/history/lincolns-missing-bodyguard-12932069/?no-ist    
Would he have been able to stop it if he was on duty? The wonderful world of
"What If?"
Fiona Brookner
I guess we will never know [if Seymour's story is true]. He was very young and if
in fact he was there, I don't think he understood what had happened until later, and
I would assume his mom would want to protect him. If there is a record of all the
attendants of that night that could corroborate his narration, it would be more
credible.

And we'll see what happens in 30 or 40 years when the last witness of the JFK
assassination appears on national TV how similar the story is.....
Ida Sanchez
I heard the CD "The Killing of Lincoln" by Bill O'Reilly and the facts you
remembered were all covered. It was a great listen.
Jim Kiser
N.B.  I read that book and really enjoyed it.  But a friend told me that some of
the facts in it had been massaged.  For example, there is a mention of the Oval
Office, but it didn't exist back then.  This is a small detail, but the friend implied
that many others had been massaged along with it.  - Q. Gen.
You are right when you say why hasn't more been written about Sarah Cook and
Mrs. Goldsboro take on this incident.  And how did they verify that Seymour
actually was there?  

There is an interesting audio clip made in 1933 of an interview with Joseph H.
Hazelton who was an errand boy at Ford's Theater and was there the night of the
assassination.  There is also an eye witness account from former Wisconsin
Governor Leonard Farwell published in 1923 who was in the Lincoln
administration.  He stated that he ran to appraise VP Andrew Johnson on the
incident fearing a conspiracy theory that might target more members of Lincoln's
administration.   Lt.  John Hutchinson also a witness seems to want to set things
straight as to what really happened in an article published in the New York Times in
1909.  As with any incident everybody's memories are different and many simply
didn't want to remember or get involved.  Or is the lack of eye witness accounts
the result of some type of a cover-up and then people's consciences getting the
better of them years later?

Hate to admit it, but I remember this episode of "I've Got a Secret".  I remembered
the episode with the old man with the cane and black eye.  Knew it had something
to do with Lincoln but had to research the name and actual incident.

Definitely will take you up on your homework assignment on Henry Rathbone.  
Edna Cardinal
I had similar thoughts myself [about whether Seymour's story was true] when I
saw this. I thought about looking for "proof" but have been rather busy this last
week. I'm going to look a while today.

I wonder if possibly they were interviewed, but the papers (if it was even recorded
in writing) lost or never published?  Are there original documents out there that we
have no access to or easy access?

I imagine the scene was very chaotic. In investigations today (where we have a
systematic, "orderly" way to investigate crimes), investigators take notes and collect
information in their head. That data doesn't always survive. There's typically no
centralized location for investigatory info.   How much more so in 1865? If they
were talked to by investigators, maybe the info they had was not overly helpful or
distinct and so not recorded.  I think about the guys I work with.... They
interviews lots of folks, but only the most helpful make the final cut.  

I have read accounts of others who were there and wrote letters or memoirs. So
your question regarding family recollection is very on point.  There are several
books compiling eyewitness accounts.  You know they researched intensely to
acquire as many accounts as possible. And nothing from this group? Hmmmm
I also note that the original article of Seymour's account was published in 1954.
That's the first documentation of his story? That's late, I think.

It does beg the question "is this true?" If no other account is found, I definitely
think it's strange. Will be reading for a while.... :)
Kim Richardson
I wondered about [the truth of the story] as well. "Our American Cousin," just
doesn't  seem like a play you would send a child of the 1800's to see.  I really
wondered where the provenance is?  I want to see the ticket stub! ;)
Nelsen Spickard
I will try to take a moment to read about Henry Rathbone.  That seems like an
extreme reaction to kill Clara .. yikes.
Tish Olshefski
Congratulations to Our Winners!

Collier Smith                Marsha Rice
Margaret Paxton                Toya McClurken
Kim Richardson                Stephen P. Hall
Donna Jolley                Valerie Thomason
Arthur Hartwell                Judy Pfaff
Fiona Brooker                Nelsen Spickard
Betty Chambers                Tynan Peterson
Bill Utterback                Dennis Brann
Ruth Brannigan                Tish Olshefski
Ellen Welker                Rebecca Bare
Beth Long                Carol Stansell
Mary Fitzpatrick Horworth
Timmy Fitzpatrick                Edna Cardinal
Daniel Jolley                Dianne Abbott
Larry Adams                Carol Farrant
Patty K                Roger Lipsett
Joshua Kreitzer                Marcelle Comeau
Milene Rawlinson                Maureen DeHaan
Susan Skidmore                Ida Sanchez
Dan Thimgan                Jim Kiser
Cindy Costigan                Sharon M Levy
Tom Collins                Venita Wilson
Valerie Cross

Grace Hertz and Mary Turner
Team Fletcher!
**********
**********
**********
A Tragedy's Second Act;
Did Col. Henry Rathbone's Agony
as an Eyewitness to the Lincoln Assassination Lead Him to
Murder His Wife, Clara Harris
18 Years Later?

By MICHAEL E. RUANE
The Washington Post
April 12, 2009
On Aug. 7, 1891, the royal Prussian physician in
the town of Hildesheim, Germany, went to a
mental asylum in a former Benedictine monastery
to examine a wealthy American who had been an
inmate there for the past eight years.

The patient's name was Henry R. Rathbone. He
was a former U.S. Army officer who had once
moved in the elite circles of Washington society
and now had exclusive quarters in the 800-year- old complex, where
he had been confined by the German courts.

The physician, one A. Rosenbach, found Mr. Rathbone thin and
graying. He was 53, stood 5-foot-11 and weighed 140 pounds. The
doctor took his pulse -- 68 beats per minute -- and temperature --
99.6. Both about normal.

The doctor noted that the patient was polite, carefully dressed, and
"earnest." He appeared healthy, although the pupil in his right eye was
larger than the left. The patient refused to discuss his mental
condition, but the asylum records spelled it out.

Henry suffered from hallucinations. He believed he was being
persecuted and tortured. He thought there was an apparatus in the
wall pouring "injurious vapors" into his head, causing headaches. He
believed he could hear people gliding suspiciously in the corridor
outside his suite.

The doctor noted two more things: Mr. Rathbone declined to discuss
his late wife, Clara, whom he had murdered in 1883 in the German
apartment in which they were living during a European tour.
And he would not talk about the assassination of President Abraham
Lincoln.

These two events, many years and an
ocean apart, seemed unrelated. The
doctor was unsure that they were
connected. But Henry R. Rathbone's
friends and relatives had long been
convinced that
they were most certainly and fatefully
linked.

Read more...
Method.

1.  Used google image search for "elderly man on tv show "I've
got a Secret" - sixth image matched the quiz photo, found the
following

"I've Got a Secret featured Samuel Seymour, a Maryland man who
was the last surviving person to witness Abraham Lincoln's death."

Tom Collins

*****
Googled "I've Got a Secret" and found the IMDb website which had
Samuel Seymour's secret as one of the trivia for the show. So then
went looking for Samuel Seymour and found several images that
suggested I was on the right track.

Really want to find out Mrs George S Goldsboro's name and whether
she was his godmother or just his father's clients wife.

Fiona Brookner
Samuel J. Seymour
mentalfloss.com/article/49050/.....
On April 12, 1956, Samuel J. Seymour
died in his daughter’s home in Arlington,
Virginia. This isn’t really noteworthy on
its own. People die every day. Mr.
Seymour was 96 years old on the day he
died, though, which means he was born
in 1860, the year before the American
Civil War began, and was the longest-
surviving witness to one of the nation’s
great tragedies.
In the spring of 1865, when Seymour was 5 years old, he joined his father on a
business trip to Washington, D.C. While the elder Seymour attended to business at his
client's estate, Samuel and his nurse were entertained by the client’s wife, Mrs.
Goldsboro.

“Sammy, you and I and Sarah are going to a play—a real play,” Seymour recalled
Goldsboro telling him. The play was called Our American Cousin, and they went to the
evening performance on April 14 at Ford’s Theater.

As they took their seats in one of the balconies, Goldsboro pointed across the theater to
a draped balcony box.

“See those flags, Sammy? That’s where President Lincoln will sit.”

When the president and his party arrived and took their seats, Goldsboro lifted Seymour
up so he could have a clear view.

“He was a tall, stern-looking man,” Seymour said of Lincoln. “I guess I just thought he
looked stern because of his whiskers, because he was smiling and waving to the
crowd.”

During the play’s third act, Seymour wrote, “all of a sudden a shot rang out—a shot
that will always be remembered—and someone in the president’s box screamed.”

Seymour didn’t actually see anyone shoot Lincoln, but he watched as the president
slumped over in his chair and a man jumped from the balcony to the stage. He landed
awkwardly, and appeared to have hurt himself.

“Hurry, hurry,” Seymour begged Goldsboro. “Let’s go help the poor man who fell
down.”

Not knowing who the man was or what he had just done, Seymour was concerned for
his well-being, but John Wilkes Booth's landing was smooth enough that he escaped the
theater and evaded pursuit for almost two weeks.

Samuel Seymour did not sleep easy when he finally escaped the commotion of the
theater and returned home.

“That night I was shot 50 times, at least, in my dreams,” Seymour later said. “And I
sometimes still relive the horror of Lincoln’s assassination, dozing in my rocker as an
old codger like me is bound to do.”

In February 1956, Seymour appeared on the TV game show I’ve Got a Secret, where
the panelists were able to guess his secret in just a few minutes. He died just a few
months later, survived by five children, 13 grandchildren and 35 great-grandchildren.
**********
**********
When a celebrity-seeking couple
crashed a White House state dinner last
November, the issue of presidential
security dominated the news. The
Secret Service responded by putting
three of its officers on administrative
leave and scrambled to reassure the
public that it takes the job of guarding
the president very seriously. “We put
forth the maximum effort all the time,”
said Secret Service spokesman Edwin
Donovan.

That kind of dedication to safeguarding
the president didn’t always exist. It
wasn’t until 1902 that the Secret
Service, created in 1865 to eradicate
counterfeit currency, assumed official
full-time responsibility for protecting
the president. Before that, security for
the president could be unbelievably lax.
The most astounding example was the
scant protection afforded Abraham
Lincoln on the night he was
assassinated. Only one man, an
unreliable Washington cop named John
Lincoln's Missing Bodyguard

What happened to Officer John Parker,
the man who chose the wrong night to leave his post at Ford's Theater?

By Paul Martin
smithsonianmag.com
April 8, 2010
www.smithsonianmag.com/history/lincolns-missing-bodyguard...
Birth: May 19, 1830
Winchester City,
Virginia

Death: Jun. 28, 1890
District Of Columbia

Bodyguard. The
night Lincoln was
Frederick Parker, was assigned to guard the president at Ford’s Theatre on April 14,
1865.

Today it’s hard to believe that a single policeman was Lincoln’s only protection, but
145 years ago the situation wasn’t that unusual. Lincoln was cavalier about his personal
safety, despite the frequent threats he received and a near-miss attempt on his life in
August 1864, as he rode a horse unescorted. He’d often take in a play or go to church
without guards, and he hated being encumbered by the military escort assigned to him.
Sometimes he walked alone at night between the White House and the War Department,
a distance of about a quarter of a mile.

John Parker was an unlikely candidate to guard a president—or anyone for that matter.
Born in Frederick County, Virginia, in 1830, Parker moved to Washington as a young
man, originally earning his living as a carpenter. He became one of the capital’s first
officers when the Metropolitan Police Force was organized in 1861. Parker’s record as
a cop fell somewhere between pathetic and comical. He was hauled before the police
board numerous times, facing a smorgasbord of charges that should have gotten him
fired. But he received nothing more than an occasional reprimand. His infractions
included conduct unbecoming an officer, using intemperate language and being drunk
on duty. Charged with sleeping on a streetcar when he was supposed to be walking his
beat, Parker declared that he’d heard ducks quacking on the tram and had climbed
aboard to investigate. The charge was dismissed. When he was brought before the
board for frequenting a whorehouse, Parker argued that the proprietress had sent for
him.

In November 1864, the Washington police force created the first permanent detail to
protect the president, made up of four officers. Somehow, John Parker was named to
the detail. Parker was the only one of the officers with a spotty record, so it was a
tragic coincidence that he drew the assignment to guard the president that evening. As
usual, Parker got off to a lousy start that fateful Friday. He was supposed to relieve
Lincoln’s previous bodyguard at 4 p.m. but was three hours late.

Lincoln’s party arrived at the theater at around 9 p.m. The play, Our American Cousin,
had already started when the president entered his box directly above the right side of
the stage. The actors paused while the orchestra struck up “Hail to the Chief.” Lincoln
bowed to the applauding audience and took his seat.

Parker was seated outside the president’s box, in the passageway beside the door.
From where he sat, Parker couldn’t see the stage, so after Lincoln and his guests
settled in, he moved to the first gallery to enjoy the play. Later, Parker committed an
even greater folly: At intermission, he joined the footman and coachman of Lincoln’s
carriage for drinks in the Star Saloon next door to Ford’s Theatre.

John Wilkes Booth entered the theater around 10 p.m.. Ironically, he’d also been in the
Star Saloon, working up some liquid courage. When Booth crept up to the door to
Lincoln’s box, Parker’s chair stood empty. Some of the audience may not have heard
the fatal pistol shot, since Booth timed his attack to coincide with a scene in the play
that always sparked loud laughter.

Read more...
Joseph H. Hazelton
Another candidatey for the "Last Living Witness"
to the Lincoln Assassination
archive.org/stream/accountsofassassefhlinc#page/n25/mode/2up
Joseph M. Hazelton (ca. 1853 – 8 October 1936), aka Joseph Hazleton, was an
American stage and film actor. He appeared in 30 films between 1912 and 1922. As a
boy program giver at Ford's Theatre, he witnessed the assassination of President
Abraham Lincoln. He died in Los Angeles, California, USA.
**********
XXX
For more accounts of the
Lincoln assassination,
click
here.
Product Details
Paperback: 226 pages
Publisher: University Press of
Mississippi (February 1, 1996)
Language: English
ISBN-10: 087805779X
ISBN-13: 978-0878057795

Order
here.